Grade the Trade: Anfernee Simons goes East, Blazers continue rebuilding

Portland acquires Cole Anthony and draft capital from Orlando

Note: It will not likely matter, but Denver’s 2025 first-round pick in this proposal is top-five protected through 2027.

This season, Simons averaged a career-high in points (22.6 per game), assists (5.5), and rebounds (3.6). His offensive-minded skillset makes him an ideal fit alongside the Magic's rising stars, Paolo Banchero and Franz Wagner. As a guard, Simons brings elite shooting and the ability to initiate the offense when needed, potentially adding a new dimension to Orlando.

"Half-court shot-making and facilitation top the Magic's offseason wish list, and they have the assets to address both. Going after Simons comes close to doing so in one player. He isn't a bold-text game manager, but he has improved his live-dribble reads over the past few years. Secondary orchestration also goes a long way when Paolo Banchero is already in place."

- Dan Favale

Simons, 25, is a perfect fit for the Magic's young core. The team already has a solid lineup of guards, including Cole Anthony, Jalen Suggs, and Markelle Fultz. While all three have shown promise, Simons stands out with his consistent shooting and ability to stretch the floor. This is a valuable asset for the team, especially considering that the best out of the group, Suggs and Fultz, aren't consistent shooters at this point in their careers.

The Magic have built their team identity around their length and versatility. Players like Jonathan Issac, Franz Wagner, and Paolo Banchero, all 6-foot-10, contribute to this strategy. Simons is an undersized guard at 6-foot-3 and is a defensive liability. However, the Magic's roster construction would help compensate for his weaknesses.

Given his age, playmaking, and shooting ability, it makes sense for the Magic to acquire Simons. But do they give the Blazers enough in return to make the deal worthwhile?